Not-So-Obvious Pinterest Tips for Influencers
Today, I am breaking down some common mistakes I see influencers making on Pinterest, and how to fix them. As a Pinterest manager for the past 3 years, I have seen and heard it all! And I do see a lot of bad advice being taken and executed on the platform.
Also, I hate posts that just regurgitate the same advice that honestly you could easily find on any other site! Or even just in Pinterest’s Help section. So, if it’s surprising to you that advice like repinning the same pin to different boards is no longer best practice, then some of these might be a little over your head! You’ve been warned.
So, let’s dive into some common mistakes I see, that most influencers don’t even realize are mistakes!

Mistake #1: Pinning Only Your Own Content
Okay, so this one will get some eyebrow raises if you’re up to date on Pinterest strategy. Many experts say that as creators, we should only be focused on creating fresh pins, and repinning other user’s content is a waste of time.
And honestly, they’re right for the most part. Most of your time should absolutely be spent creating and sharing your own content. But, there is a strategic reason for placing third party pins on your boards!
Especially when you first start an account or if you create a new board. You want to ensure that the algorithm knows what your account and board are all about, so that it doesn’t waste any time guessing who to show your content to.
If you’re going to pin third party pins, they must meet the following criteria:
- They must be strongly related to the topic/keyword of the board name they are being pinned to
- They must be a top search result for any related keywords to the board they are being pinned to
The reason these are strategic is that you are tipping the algorithm off to what your content is all about, and what types of pins and creators to associate your account with. A high performing, popular pin in your niche? Definitely something you want your account to be associated with.
I really only recommend utilizing this strategy when you’re creating a new board or trying to re-optimize and old underperforming board.
Mistake #2: Trying to Grow Your Follower Count
This one is shocking to most, so I’ll let you take it in a moment…
Yes, growing your followers is not the way to go with Pinterest. Probably the most important thing to understand about Pinterest is the intent behind the users. If you use Pinterest yourself, you’re usually using it for planning purposes. You’re planning a wedding, need a new recipe, renovating your kitchen, or trying to find some trendy outfit ideas for the upcoming season.
You’re not on there to mindlessly scroll, socialize, or follow along with an influencer’s day to day life. It’s just not what people are doing, and so growing your following is pretty useless.
People are searching specific ideas and gathering them for later. Your goal is to be the best idea for every search term related to your content.
If you need another convincing reason why growing a following on Pinterest isn’t useful, have you ever seen the Pinterest homefeed? It’s basically a giant discovery page that very rarely features anyone you actually follow. Pinterest wants to show users new and exciting things they’ve never seen before(hence why they want fresh pins, not repins). That’s like, Pinterest’s whole claim to fame.

Mistake #3: Creating Video Pins
I know, another shocking one, especially for influencers! But like I said before, users are here to search for ideas, and then act on them later! The main goal of Pinterest for influencers is not to grow a following, but to use it like the search engine it is.
It’s basically like Google, but without the competition and you can use images. So, you want to put the right keywords in your pin title and description, and then you want your image to capture your ideal audience’s attention and entice them to click!
Pinterest is best used as a traffic driver to your blog OR if you don’t have a blog yet, your affiliate platform of choice. (I strongly recommend a blog, but thats another topic!)
So, how does this relate to video? Videos are a fantastic way to keep users on the Pinterest platform LONGER. Which, we don’t want. We want them clicking off Pinterest and onto our links! But this is why Pinterest has encouraged and even incentivized creators to utilize video on their platform.
Why? The longer people stay on Pinterest, the more money Pinterest makes! They can’t serve ads to someone who isn’t scrolling.
So if you thought Pinterest had your best interest at heart when they started those paid programs for creating Video pins, think again!
Mistake #4: Repurposing All Your Existing Content
Okay I’ll admit I wanted shock value with that title, because you definitely should be repurposing your existing content. But I have 2 stipulations to this that a lot of people ignore or just don’t even know that can make a huge difference between success and failure on the platform:
- Don’t repurpose ALL of your existing content. I had a client one time tell me she had been told that every single blog post on her site must have a pin associated with it. This just isn’t true. If it’s a topic that isn’t being searched on Pinterest OR isn’t related to your niche (your life update type blog posts for example) then you definitely should not create pins for that content.
- Don’t just plop your image and link into Pinterest and think that’s enough! You should try putting some text overlay on your image, adding a search engine optimized title and description and ensuring it’s pinned to a keyword optimized board very closely related to the topic.
Mistake #4: Pinning Inconsistently
How many pins should I be pinning per day? Probably the number 1 asked question I get when I’m doing account audits. And the answer is never straightforward.
You have to pin consistently, and you have to pick a cadence that you can reliably keep up with. That’s it. That’s going to perform best long term. Yes, the more you pin, the faster you’ll see results, but if pinning 20 fresh pins per day is going to burn you out and make you inconsistent, then- it’s not a good strategy.
Mistake #5: Assuming What Your Audience Wants
This is the difference between this being a hobby and this being business right here. So many influencers create content based on what they want to create content on. Sure, it may be trending, or some other influencers posted something like it and it looks like it’s doing well so why not try? Or I just bought this great thing I bet other people will like it too.
This is not a reliable or strategic way to create content. I know as creators it’s hard to think this way, but researching what your audience actually wants, and what they are struggling with is the best way to ensure your content performs.
Keyword research is your friend. Seeing the volume of how many people search a particular terms tells you right away if this is something worth creating content surrounding. Coming up with a list of keywords related to your audience’s most asked questions is THE fastest way to grow and gain trust.

Mistake #6: Spending Hours on Keyword Research
You can easily spend waaay too much time looking up keywords! And with everything else to keep up with, Tiktok, IG, LTK, the list goes on. Who has time for that? I have an amazing and super quick keyword research strategy that I only share with my account audit clients. But, I have now decided to share for free!
Simply sign up here and you’ll get a link to the video in your email (you’ll also be added to an email list where I send out Pinterest strategy tips, but you can unsubscribe if you’re not interested!)
I’ll be honest, I only know about these mistakes because I made themself when I first started out! So I hope you can learn from MY mistakes and supercharge your results much faster than mine happened!
Now that I’ve had my own fashion blog since 2019 and my Pinterest management business since 2021, I know a thing or two about how to succeed on Pinterest.
If you’re ready to outsource your Pinterest, or get a tailored plan you can enact yourself or hand off to a VA, be sure to check out our monthly management packages or account audits!
Leave a Reply